Menu

Tue – Wed: 3 PM – 9 PM
Thu – Sat: 3 PM – 10 PM
Call 414-964-2611 to order

    • Starters

    • Breaded Eggplant

      15.00

      sugo, fresh mozzarella

    • Carciofi

      15.00

      long stem artichoke heart, toasted breadcrumbs, lemon, evoo

    • Olive Tapenade

      12.00

      crostini

    • Caprese

      13.00

      fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil

    • Olive Medley

      11.00

    • Bruschetta

      15.00

      tomato, basil, garlic, parmesan

    • Baked Goat Cheese

      15.00

      tomato basil sauce

    • Garlic Bread

      12.50

    • Garlic Bread with Cheese

      13.50

    • Sides

    • Pasta in Sugo

      10.00

    • Wilted Spinach

      10.00

    • Meatball in Sauce

      10.00

    • Italian Sausage

      10.00

    • Salads

      Add protein to your salad: chicken +10 / salmon or sauteed shrimp +15

    • Caesar

      7.5 / 13.5

      home made croutons, parmesan*

    • Arugula

      11.00

      parmesan, lemon poppyseed vinaigrette

    • House

      5 / 10

      greens, tomato, onion, carrot

    • Spinach

      13.50

      goat cheese, strawberry, walnut, balsamic vinaigrette

    • Soup

      9.00

      house made soup of the day or minestrone

    • Entrees

      Includes choice of side salad or cup of soup. Side caesar 4.95 (dine-in only)

    • Sugo

      22.00

      our family's tomato, basil & parmesan sauce, angel hair

    • Sugo d'Menfi

      24.00

      our sugo sauce with artichoke hearts & kalamata olives, angel hair

    • Verde

      24.00

      spinach, portabella & button mushrooms, zucchini, onion, spicy garlic olive oil, penne

      with chicken or Italian sausage 26 / with sauteed shrimp 32

    • Meatballs

      26.00

      stewed in tomato sauce, angel hair

    • Arrabbiata

      26.00

      Italian sausage, spicy tomato sauce, penne

    • Gnocchi

      26.00

      spinach & gorgonzola cream sauce

    • Alfredo

      22.00

      linguine

      with chicken 24 / with shrimp 32

    • Da Mare

      34.00

      sauteed shrimp, sea scallops, tomato cream sauce, linguine

    • Bolognese

      34.00

      veal, pork, beef, pancetta, & prosciutto stewed in tomato sauce, penne

    • Saporito

      36.00

      sauteed shrimp, fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic, white wine butter sauce, linguine

    • Salmon

      32.00

      Sicilian 'salsa' |tomatoes, white onion, & capers| - over wilted spinach*

    • Parmesan

      32.00

      breaded, tomato sauce & mozzarella, angel hair

      your choice - chicken breast | pork tenderloin cutlets

    • Marsala

      28.00

      portabella & button mushrooms, sweet marsala reduction, angel hair

      your choice - chicken breast | pork tenderloin medallions

    • Beef Tenderloin

      MKT

      port wine demi glaze, onion, button, portabella, crispy Yukon Gold potatoes

    • Specialty Pizza

    • Papa Tony's

      20 / 24

      pepperoni & goat cheese

    • Tuscan Countryside

      20 / 24

      sausage, Kalamata olives & goat cheese

    • Flag of Italy

      20 / 24

      fresh tomato, green olive & fresh basil

    • Primavera

      20 / 26

      mushroom, artichoke, onion, red & green pepper

    • Sicilian Supreme

      32 / 34

      sausage, prosciutto, green & black olives, mushroom, onion, green pepper

    • Margherita

      22 / 26

      fresh mozzarella, tomato & basil with garlic olive oil

    • Rita

      20 / 26

      fresh mozzarella, banana peppers, onion, prosciutto

    • Mediterranean

      22 / 26

      chicken breast, fresh basil, goat cheese, Kalamata olive, garlic olive oil

    • Build Your Own Pizza

    • Cheese Pizza

      12.5 / 16.5

      small: 10" / large: 14"

    • Traditional Toppings

      2.5 / 3.75

      sausage
      spinach
      pepperoni
      tomato
      anchovy
      artichoke
      mushroom
      banana pepper
      green pepper
      pepperoncini
      red pepper
      green olive
      white onion
      black olive
      red onion
      fresh basil
      garlic

    • Gourmet Toppings

      3 / 4.25

      pancetta
      fresh mozzarella
      prosciutto
      cream cheese
      capicola
      goat cheese
      chicken
      gorgonzola
      meatballs
      ricotta
      portabella
      Boursin
      capers
      double crust
      asparagus
      Kalamata olive

    • Gluten Free Crust

      5.50

      made locally by Schroeter's Gluten Free Bake Shop

    • Take & Bake Family Meals

    • Bolognese with Caesar Salad

      75.00

      Bolognese (with beef, pork, veal, prosciutto & pancetta) over penne / Caesar salad / Garlic bread. Serves 4. Bakes in about 20 minutes.

    • Sugo Penne with House Salad

      60.00

      Baked penne with our sugo sauce and mozzarella / House salad with Italian vinaigrette / Garlic bread. Serves 4. Bakes in about 20 minutes.

    • Desserts

    • Tiramisu

      12.00

    • Flourless Chocolate Cake

      10.00

    • Traditional Cannoli

      10.00

*Eating certain raw or undercooked foods may increase your risk of foodborne illness

All items are subject to availability and change

20% gratuity may be added to parties of 6 or more